Croft vs cash advance apps
Checked . Every fact about Gerald, EarnIn and Dave on this page comes from each app's own pages, listed under Sources. Prices and features change, so check each app's site for the latest.
Croft suits people paying down card and loan debt who want to know what's safe to pay from each paycheck without coming up short before payday. Gerald, EarnIn and Dave each send you money before payday, and it's paid back later.[2][3][4]
14 days free, then less than 40¢ a day ($11.99 billed monthly). Card required. Cancel anytime.
Side by side
| Feature | Croft | Gerald, EarnIn and Dave |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $11.99/month or $89/year. | Gerald: no interest, no fees and no late charges.[1]EarnIn: no mandatory fees or interest on standard transfers, and tips are optional. Faster transfers start at $3.99.[3]Dave: a membership fee of up to $5 a month, and an overdraft fee on each ExtraCash of $5 or 5%, whichever is greater. An optional 1.5% fee applies to transfers to an outside debit card.[4] |
| Free trial | 14 days free. Card required. Cancel anytime. | Not stated* |
| Approach | Plans each paycheck: bills and minimum payments first, a cushion in checking, then what's safe to put toward debt. | Gerald: cash advances of $40 to $200, plus Buy Now, Pay Later in its own store, Cornerstore. Part of an advance must be spent at Cornerstore before the rest can go to your bank.[1]EarnIn: Cash Out sends part of your upcoming paycheck early, up to $200 a day and $1,000 a pay period. Limits vary.[3]Dave: ExtraCash of $25 to $500, repayable on demand. Not all members qualify, and few qualify for $500.[4] |
| Connects to your bank | Yes, read-only through Plaid. Croft can't move money. | Gerald: yes. You connect your bank account and link its debit card.[2][1]EarnIn: yes. You download the app and connect your bank.[3]Dave: yes. You link your bank to qualify, and ExtraCash needs a Dave Checking account.[4] |
| Platforms | Web app. | Gerald: Android and iOS apps.[2]EarnIn: apps on the App Store and Google Play.[3]Dave: iOS and Android apps. Managing your account and getting ExtraCash require the app.[4] |
| Shows what's safe to pay right now | Yes. One number for what can go to debt today, updated whenever anything changes. | Not stated* |
| Shows your lowest balance before payday | Yes. The lowest your checking gets before your next paycheck, and the day. | Not stated*EarnIn lists Balance Shield, which can send alerts when your balance is low.[3] |
| Debt payoff plan with a date | Yes. Every card and loan in one plan, with your debt-free date. | Not stated* |
| Finds your bills automatically | Yes. Croft drafts your bills and paychecks from your checking for you to review. | Not stated* |
* Not stated: we didn't find this on the Gerald, EarnIn and Dave pages listed under Sources as of Nov 12, 2026. It may still be offered; check each app's site.
Where Croft stands on advances
Croft doesn't lend money or offer advances, and it won't suggest one. An advance moves money from your next payday to today. The app is paid back first, so the next pay period starts short, often by about the same amount, and it's easy to tap again.
Croft works on the other end of that: it shows what's safe to pay right now and the low point before payday, so a short week shows up before it arrives.
If you use advances now, our guide shows how to step down without leaving one paycheck to cover the whole gap, and the calculator adds up how much more went out than came in.
Questions people ask
How much does Dave cost?
As of Nov 12, 2026, Dave's site lists a membership fee of up to $5 a month, and an overdraft fee on each ExtraCash of $5 or 5%, whichever is greater.
Does EarnIn charge fees?
As of Nov 12, 2026, EarnIn's site says standard transfers have no mandatory fees or interest and tips are optional. Faster Lightning Speed transfers start at $3.99.
Does Gerald charge fees?
As of Nov 12, 2026, Gerald's site says it charges no interest, no fees and no late charges. Part of an advance must be spent in its store, Cornerstore, before the rest can go to your bank.
Does Croft offer cash advances?
No. Croft doesn't lend money or offer advances, and it won't suggest one. It plans each paycheck: bills and minimum payments first, a cushion in checking, then what's safe to put toward debt.
Does Croft move my money?
No. Croft connects to your bank through Plaid to read balances and transactions. It can't move money out of your bank or make payments from your accounts. When Croft suggests a payment, you make it yourself at your bank or card issuer.
Is there a free trial?
Yes. Creating your account and setting up cost nothing. Your 14-day free trial starts when you add a card, just before your plan. After that, it's less than 40¢ a day: $11.99 billed monthly, or $89 a year.
Sources, checked
- Gerald: Home page: https://joingerald.com/
- Gerald: How it works: https://joingerald.com/how-it-works
- EarnIn: Home page: https://www.earnin.com/
- Dave: Home page: https://dave.com/
Gerald, EarnIn and Dave are trademarks of their owners. Croft isn't affiliated with or endorsed by any of them.
You're not bad with money. You're busy.
14 days free, then less than 40¢ a day ($11.99 billed monthly). Card required. Cancel anytime.
New to Croft? Read what Croft is and how it handles your data.